Enhanced – Listen: to the audio article
Raising Lifelong Learners title
with
Colleen Kessler, M.Ed.
with
Colleen Kessler, M.Ed.
Join Colleen in The Learners Lab
A community of parents with differently-wired kids—children and teens who are empathetic, sensitive, brilliant, intensely driven, ambitious, always moving, creative, and ready to take on the world. But they aren’t always easy. They need a different approach. In The Learner’s Lab, you’ll find both the resources and the support you need to help your children succeed and feel more connected as a family.
Beyond Knowing: Raising Kids
Who Know What to Do with What They Learn
There is a particular kind of comfort that comes from checking boxes.
✅ Math lesson finished.
✅ Spelling words practiced.
✅ Chapter read.
✅ Dates memorized.
✅ Worksheet completed.
As

  homeschool parents, we can look at a stack of finished work and think, “There. We learned something today.” And we probably did. But after years of teaching—first in traditional classrooms and then around my own kitchen table—I’ve become increasingly convinced that one of the most important questions we can ask about our children’s education isn’t simply, “What do they know?” but “What can they do with what they know?” That, I think, is where we begin moving from knowledge toward wisdom.

Knowledge matters. Our children need facts. They need vocabulary and background knowledge. They need to understand mathematical concepts, scientific principles, history, literature, and the ideas that have shaped the world around them. But knowledge is the raw material of an education. It isn’t the finished product.

Wisdom requires our children to make connections, ask good questions, evaluate information, solve problems, communicate ideas, recognize when they don’t know something, and decide what to do next. And homeschooling gives us an incredible opportunity to practice those things every single day.

“Knowledge is the raw material of an education, but it isn’t the finished product.”
When Knowing
Isn’t the Same as Learning
One of my daughters has always been creative and theatrical. She loves stories and performing, but creepy-crawly science? Not so much.

Years ago, though, I was teaching a class at our co-op to her age group all about the organisms that live in and around rotting logs. She was not thrilled about the tank of insects and arthropods I had to use as a teaching tool. She wanted no part of touching, exploring, or even observing those creatures, and a few of the other kids felt the same. I challenged them to find a different way to learn what the rest of the group was learning instead of participating in the hands-on activities and lessons. Instead of simply reading the material, answering the questions, and moving on, she and her friends turned what they were learning into a performance.

They researched the organisms. They decided how to represent them. They wrote and rehearsed a play, created costumes, worked together, and eventually performed their wonderfully memorable “Life in a Rotting Log.”

Could I have handed them worksheets about decomposers? Of course. And they probably could have completed them correctly, too. But look at what happened when the learning went further: She and her friends had to understand the content well enough to explain it. They had to decide what information mattered. They had to communicate their ideas to each other, listen to each other’s ideas, solve disagreements, compromise, create something new from what they had learned, and stand in front of an audience with enough confidence to share it.

The science content mattered, but so did everything they did with it. That distinction has shaped so much of how I think about education.

Content Is a Beginning,
Not an End
In The Homeschool Advantage, I write about the skills I believe children need to thrive: collaboration, communication, content, critical thinking, creative innovation, and confidence. As you can see, content is absolutely one of them, but it sits alongside the others for a reason.

A child can memorize the causes of the American Revolution without ever considering how ordinary people decide when a government has become unjust. She can calculate percentages without recognizing that she should check whether the “great deal” she found online actually saves money. A child can memorize the steps of the scientific method without developing the habit of asking, “How do we know this is true?” He can define bias for a vocabulary test without recognizing it in a video that appears in his social media feed.

Knowledge tells us things; Wisdom helps us decide what those things mean.
That’s why some of the richest learning in our homeschool has happened when we’ve followed rabbit trails instead of rushing back to the lesson plan. Someone asks a question at breakfast. Another wonders about something we saw on a hike. A book mentions a person we’ve never heard of, or a science experiment doesn’t work the way it was supposed to. Those moments can feel like interruptions when our goal is completing curriculum, but they become invitations when our goal is developing thinkers.
Two young girls crouching by the edge of a reflective pond in a park.
Ask Better Questions
One of the simplest ways to move learning toward wisdom is to change the questions we ask. Instead of always asking questions with one correct answer, try adding questions such as:

  • What do you think?
  • Why do you think that happened?
  • What does this remind you of?
  • How could we find out?
  • What would happen if we changed this?
  • Do you agree with the author? Why?
  • Where might we use this in real life?
  • Is there another way to solve this?

Those questions communicate something important to our children: Your thinking matters here. And that is especially important for bright, creative, twice-exceptional, and otherwise neurodivergent kids who may know an astonishing amount about certain subjects while struggling with seemingly simple academic tasks.

Your kiddo may understand complex scientific concepts and still struggle to organize a paragraph. Another may solve sophisticated math problems mentally but have difficulty showing every step on paper. And yet another may spend hours researching a favorite historical period while staring helplessly at a worksheet asking her to summarize three paragraphs.

Wisdom on our part means recognizing that performance and understanding are not always the same thing. Instead of immediately asking, “Why won’t you do this?” we can get curious: “What’s making this hard right now?” That question can change everything.

Maybe handwriting is getting in the way of communicating sophisticated ideas. We can try dictation. Maybe working memory is overloaded. We can provide a checklist. Maybe the assignment feels enormous. We can break it into smaller pieces. That isn’t lowering academic expectations, but removing an obstacle so the child can actually engage in the deeper work of learning.

Not Knowing & Evaluating
There’s another piece of wisdom that I think our children desperately need in a world where nearly any fact can be summoned in seconds: They need to become comfortable saying, “I don’t know,” and recognizing the limits of their knowledge.

When they need to find the answer, our job is to remember kids are growing up surrounded by information. Search engines, social media, videos, podcasts, artificial intelligence, friends, influencers, experts, and complete strangers are all ready to answer their questions. The challenge they face will increasingly be not finding information but evaluating it. A wise mom teaches her kids to think critically about the information they find, guiding them to become wise, too.

Evaluation is based on questions like:
  • Is this true?
  • Who says so?
  • What evidence supports it?
  • What might be missing?
  • Does another source tell the story differently?
  • What do I already know that connects to this?
  • What questions do I still have?

And, perhaps most importantly, “Am I willing to change my mind when I learn something new?”

Profile view of a young blonde girl in a mint sweatshirt resting her chin in her hand while seated at a desk.
We’re Raising Learners, Not Transcript Builders
One of the greatest gifts homeschooling offers us is the ability to take a longer view of education. We can prepare our children for college, careers, tests, transcripts, and whatever comes next without allowing those things to become the sole purpose of learning.

We are raising humans who will come up against problems we can’t predict, technologies that don’t yet exist, people who think differently than they do, conflicting information, difficult decisions, unique opportunities, and questions that cannot be answered in the back of a textbook.

They will need knowledge. Lots of it. But they’ll also need curiosity to keep learning, critical thinking to evaluate what they discover, creativity to imagine possibilities, communication and collaboration to work with others, and confidence to act when they don’t have every answer.

Our job, then, isn’t just to fill our children’s heads. It’s to help them become people who wonder, question, connect, discern, create, and act.

So yes, teach the multiplication tables. Read the history book. Practice spelling. Learn the parts of the cell. Build that beautiful foundation of knowledge. But then keep going. Ask, “What do you think?” Ask, “Why does this matter?” Ask, “What could you do with this?”

And sometimes, when nobody knows the answer, say the words that may lead to the wisest learning of all:

“I don’t know. Let’s find out together.”

-Colleen
Colleen Kessler headshot
C

olleen Kessler believes that you are the absolute best teacher there is for your amazing child. The author of more than a dozen books, award-winning educator, educational consultant, and passionate advocate for the needs of differently-wired kids, Colleen has a B.S. in elementary education, an M.Ed. in gifted studies, and is the founder of the popular podcast and website Raising Lifelong Learners and The Learner’s Lab, a membership community for quirky and creative families. Her newest book, Raising Resilient Sons: A Boy Mom’s Guide to Building a Strong, Confident, and Emotionally Intelligent Family can be found anywhere books are sold. Colleen lives in Northeast Ohio with her reading specialist husband, four delightfully differently-wired kiddos, pug, border collie, and an ever-changing assortment of small animals and insects.